Short answer: They differ in how thermal expansion is absorbed and whether the tube bundle can be removed for cleaning.
Why
Shell and tubes run at different temperatures and expand differently; if both tube sheets are welded to the shell, large stresses arise.
How
- Fixed tube sheet (BEM): cheapest, no bundle removal, shell side not mechanically cleanable; small ΔT or an expansion bellows.
- U-tube (BEU): one tube sheet, free expansion, bundle removable; tube interiors hard to clean mechanically.
- Floating head (AES): one tube sheet floats, full cleaning access; most expensive; common for dirty refinery services.
Likely focus at
IOCL, HPCL, BPCL, NRL, MRPL, CPCL, ONGC, Oil India, GAIL, BCPL, EIL. Organisation names show where a topic is a likely focus because of what the organisation does; they are not claims that a particular question was asked. Recruitment routes change each year, so confirm in the official notification.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between fixed tube sheet, U-tube and floating-head exchangers?
They differ in how thermal expansion is absorbed and whether the tube bundle can be removed for cleaning. Why: Shell and tubes run at different temperatures and expand differently; if both tube sheets are welded to the shell, large stresses arise.
Related questions
- Why is counter-current flow preferred in heat exchangers?
- Which fluid goes on the tube side of a shell-and-tube exchanger, and why?
- What is fouling? How does it affect a heat exchanger and how is it controlled?
- Why is steam used as a heating medium? Why saturated rather than superheated steam?
- What is a steam trap? Name the types.
- Explain the working of a fired heater (furnace) in a refinery.