IITIAN1997 STUDIO

Instrumentation & control: interview questions

12 questions · PID, fail-safe valves, cascade, DCS, SIL, P&ID tags

Practise with animations →

Explain P, PI and PID control. What does each term do?

Answer. P responds to present error (leaves offset), I removes offset by acting on accumulated error, D anticipates by acting on rate of change.

Why. Proportional action alone needs some error to hold a new output, hence offset. Integral keeps changing output until error is zero. Derivative damps oscillation but amplifies noise.

How.

  1. Flow loops: PI, fast, little D.
  2. Level: P or PI (averaging control for surge drums).
  3. Temperature: PID, slow processes benefit from D.
  4. Tuning: Ziegler–Nichols, Cohen–Coon, or step tests with IMC rules.

Only in industry. Most plant loops are PI; D is rarely used because transmitter noise makes valves chatter. Many loops run in manual — finding and fixing them is a classic graduate-engineer project.

Open this question

What is the difference between fail-open and fail-close valves? How do you decide?

Answer. The fail position is where the valve goes on loss of air or signal; choose the position that makes the process safe.

Why. Instrument air or power can fail; the valve spring then drives it to one end.

How.

  1. Fuel gas to a furnace: fail close (air-to-open).
  2. Cooling water to a reactor: fail open (air-to-close).
  3. Feed to a reactor: fail close; flare/blowdown valves often fail open.
  4. Fail-last (lock in place) where neither is safe.

Open this question

What is cascade control? Give an example.

Answer. Two loops in series: the output of a master (outer) controller sets the setpoint of a slave (inner) controller that acts faster.

Why. Disturbances entering the inner loop are corrected before they affect the slow outer variable.

How.

  1. Reactor temperature (master) → steam flow (slave).
  2. Column bottom temperature → reboiler steam flow.
  3. Drum level → feedwater flow.
  4. The inner loop must be 3–5 times faster than the outer loop.

Open this question

What is feed-forward and ratio control?

Answer. Feed-forward measures a disturbance and corrects before it affects the output; ratio control keeps one flow in a fixed proportion to another.

Why. Feedback can only act after an error appears; feed-forward acts early when the disturbance is measurable.

How.

  1. Fuel–air ratio in furnaces and boilers.
  2. Reflux proportional to feed.
  3. Three-element boiler drum level: level (feedback) + steam flow (feed-forward) + feedwater flow (cascade).

Open this question

What is the difference between DCS, PLC and SCADA?

Answer. DCS: continuous process control of a whole plant from a control room. PLC: fast logic and sequencing (machines, interlocks). SCADA: supervision of geographically spread assets (pipelines, wells).

Why. Different strengths: DCS for many analog PID loops and operator graphics; PLC for discrete fast logic; SCADA for telemetry over long distances.

How.

  1. Safety instrumented systems (ESD/SIS) are separate from the DCS, often triple-redundant PLCs.
  2. Pipelines use SCADA with RTUs at stations.

Open this question

How is level measured in a pressurised vessel?

Answer. Commonly by differential-pressure transmitters, displacers, radar, or guided-wave radar, with gauge glasses for local reading.

Why. In a closed vessel the gas pressure acts on both legs of a DP cell, so ΔP = ρgh gives level; the reference leg corrects for vessel pressure.

How.

  1. DP: high side at bottom nozzle, low side at top (dry or wet leg).
  2. Radar: non-contact, good for tanks.
  3. Nuclear (gamma) level for very hot or sticky services.
  4. Calibrate for liquid density; foam and density change cause errors.

Open this question

What is a thermocouple and how does it work? Compare with RTD.

Answer. Two dissimilar metals joined produce an emf proportional to the temperature difference between hot and cold junctions (Seebeck effect). RTDs measure resistance change of platinum.

Why. Different metals have different electron densities; heating the junction drives a small voltage.

How.

  1. Type K (−200 to 1250 °C) most common; type R/S for furnaces.
  2. Cold-junction compensation needed.
  3. RTD (Pt100): more accurate and stable, up to ~600 °C, slower.
  4. Thermowells protect sensors but add lag.

Open this question

What is a control valve characteristic? Linear vs equal percentage.

Answer. The relation between valve opening and flow at constant ΔP: linear (flow ∝ opening), equal percentage (each step adds a fixed % of existing flow), quick opening.

Why. Installed behaviour depends on how much of the system pressure drop the valve takes; equal-percentage valves become nearly linear when the valve takes a small share of ΔP.

How.

  1. Equal percentage: most process loops (pressure, temperature, flow with varying ΔP).
  2. Linear: level control and where valve ΔP is constant.
  3. Quick opening: on/off and relief duty.
  4. Size so normal flow is at 50–70 % opening.

Open this question

What is SIL and what is a safety instrumented function?

Answer. A SIF is an automatic trip (sensor, logic solver, final element) that brings a process to a safe state; SIL (1–4) states how reliable it must be.

Why. Risk reduction must match the hazard: SIL 1 reduces risk 10–100 times, SIL 2 100–1000, SIL 3 1000–10 000.

How.

  1. Identify hazards (HAZOP), set target via LOPA.
  2. Design redundancy (2oo3 voting), proof testing intervals.
  3. Standards: IEC 61508/61511.

Only in industry. Interlock bypasses must be authorised and logged; bypassed trips are a common finding in incident investigations.

Open this question

How do you read a P&ID? What do the instrument tag letters mean?

Answer. P&IDs show all equipment, lines, valves and instruments. Tags follow ISA: first letter the variable (F flow, T temperature, L level, P pressure, A analysis), next letters the function (I indicate, C control, T transmit, V valve, S switch, A alarm, Z safety/position).

Why. They are the master document for operation, HAZOP, maintenance and isolation; reading them fluently is expected on day one.

How.

  1. FIC-101: flow indicating controller in loop 101; FT transmitter; FV valve.
  2. LSHH: level switch high-high (trip); PSV: pressure safety valve.
  3. Line numbers carry size, fluid code, class and insulation.
  4. Solid lines process, dashed electrical/signal, line-with-hash pneumatic.

Only in industry. Every permit, isolation and modification refers to the P&ID; red-lined P&IDs after field changes (MOC) must be updated — an often-asked practical point.

Open this question

What is a first-order system and time constant?

Answer. A system whose output responds exponentially to a step: y = KΔu(1 − e^(−t/τ)); after one time constant it reaches 63.2 %.

Why. One storage element (tank, thermal mass) with a resistance gives one exponential; τ = storage × resistance.

How.

  1. Transfer function G(s) = K/(τs + 1).
  2. Thermometer lag, tank level, heated tank.
  3. Two first-order systems in series give a sigmoid (S-shaped) response.

Open this question

How do you control the temperature of an exothermic reactor?

Answer. By removing heat through a jacket, coil or external exchanger with a cascade loop (temperature master, coolant flow or temperature slave), with interlocks on high temperature.

Why. Heat release rises exponentially with temperature; the control loop must react faster than the reaction can run away.

How.

  1. Cascade: reactor TIC → jacket inlet TIC or coolant FIC.
  2. Limit feed addition rate (semi-batch) via temperature override.
  3. High-high temperature trips stop feed and open emergency cooling.

Open this question

Organisation names show where a topic is a likely focus because of what the organisation does; they are not claims that a particular question was asked. Recruitment routes change each year, so confirm in the official notification.

Practise with animations →