IITIAN1997 STUDIO

How do you choose between a centrifugal and a positive-displacement pump?

Pumps, piping & fluid flow · interview question with WHY and HOW

Ask your own question →

Short answer: Centrifugal for large flows of low-viscosity liquids at moderate head; positive displacement for high pressure, low flow, viscous liquids, accurate metering or where flow must be constant regardless of pressure.

Why

A centrifugal pump’s flow changes with system resistance and its efficiency collapses above ~200–500 cP. A PD pump delivers a fixed volume per stroke or revolution, so flow is almost independent of discharge pressure.

How

  1. Centrifugal: water, hydrocarbons, cooling water, transfer pumps; controlled by throttling or speed.
  2. Reciprocating: high-pressure injection (chemicals, glycol), boiler feed for small units, hydrotest.
  3. Rotary (gear, screw, lobe): viscous oils, bitumen, polymers.
  4. Metering (diaphragm) pumps: chemical dosing — corrosion inhibitor, antifoam, caustic.
  5. PD pumps must have a relief valve on the discharge and are never started against a closed valve.

Likely focus at

IOCL, HPCL, BPCL, NRL, MRPL, CPCL, ONGC, Oil India, GAIL, BCPL, EIL. Organisation names show where a topic is a likely focus because of what the organisation does; they are not claims that a particular question was asked. Recruitment routes change each year, so confirm in the official notification.

Frequently asked questions

How do you choose between a centrifugal and a positive-displacement pump?

Centrifugal for large flows of low-viscosity liquids at moderate head; positive displacement for high pressure, low flow, viscous liquids, accurate metering or where flow must be constant regardless of pressure. Why: A centrifugal pump’s flow changes with system resistance and its efficiency collapses above ~200–500 cP. A PD pump delivers a fixed volume per stroke or revolution, so flow is almost independent of discharge pressure.

Related questions

Ask your own question →