IITIAN1997 STUDIO

How do you choose between a tray column and a packed column?

Distillation & separations · interview question with WHY and HOW

Ask your own question →

Short answer: Packed columns for small diameters, low pressure drop (vacuum), corrosive or foaming systems; trays for large diameters, high liquid rates, fouling services and where side draws are needed.

Why

Packing gives more interfacial area per ΔP but is sensitive to liquid distribution; trays are robust, easy to inspect and handle wide load ranges.

How

  1. Structured packing in vacuum columns and revamps for capacity.
  2. Random packing (Pall rings, saddles) in absorbers and strippers.
  3. Distributors and redistributors are critical in packed beds.

Likely focus at

IOCL, HPCL, BPCL, NRL, MRPL, CPCL, ONGC, Oil India, GAIL, BCPL, EIL, BARC. Organisation names show where a topic is a likely focus because of what the organisation does; they are not claims that a particular question was asked. Recruitment routes change each year, so confirm in the official notification.

Frequently asked questions

How do you choose between a tray column and a packed column?

Packed columns for small diameters, low pressure drop (vacuum), corrosive or foaming systems; trays for large diameters, high liquid rates, fouling services and where side draws are needed. Why: Packing gives more interfacial area per ΔP but is sensitive to liquid distribution; trays are robust, easy to inspect and handle wide load ranges.

Related questions

Ask your own question →