Design types and codes (ASME VIII, IS 2825, TEMA), vessel thickness, double-pipe and shell-and-tube exchangers (Kern), triple-effect evaporators, FUG distillation, tray and packed column sizing, condensers and reboilers from the ASTU CHE241504 syllabus.
What is inside
- Vessel and head thickness by ASME VIII
- Double-pipe and shell-and-tube design
- Multiple-effect evaporators
- Columns, condensers and kettle reboilers
Syllabus: ASTU CHE241504 Process Equipment Design-I, semester 5, NEP 2020 (2024-25 onwards). Official syllabus PDF.
Introduction: design types, codes and standards
Topics: Importance of design; types of design (process, mechanical, plant); codes and standards.
What design involves, and the codes that govern it
Design turns a process idea into equipment that can be built, operated safely and paid for. Process design fixes what each unit must do: flows, compositions, temperatures, pressures, duties, number of stages, areas and sizes, from material and energy balances, equilibrium and rate data. Mechanical design makes the equipment strong and buildable: material selection, wall and head thickness, nozzles, supports, flanges and gaskets, allowing for pressure, temperature, wind, seismic and corrosion. Plant design arranges the whole plant: layout, piping, utilities, instrumentation, safety systems and cost. Design is iterative and always a compromise between capital cost, operating cost, safety, operability and maintenance.
Data come from handbooks (Perry, Sinnott, Kern, Ludwig), physical-property databanks and simulators, vendor data and plant experience. Codes and standards encode safe practice and are often legal requirements: ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section VIII (unfired pressure vessels), IS 2825 (Indian code for unfired pressure vessels), TEMA standards for shell-and-tube exchangers (classes R for refinery service, C for commercial, B for chemical), IS 4503 (shell-and-tube exchangers), API 650 and IS 803 for storage tanks, API 520/521 for relief systems, ASME B31.3 for process piping, and IBR (Indian Boiler Regulations) for steam equipment. Standards also fix preferred pipe and tube sizes, flange ratings and material grades so that parts are interchangeable.
Safety enters design through design pressure and temperature margins (design pressure typically 5–10 % or 1–2 bar above the maximum operating pressure), corrosion allowance (1.5–3 mm for carbon steel), joint efficiency for welds (depending on radiography), hydrostatic testing, relief devices sized for the worst credible case, and hazard studies (HAZOP) on the P&ID.
- Process, mechanical and plant design.
- ASME VIII / IS 2825 vessels; TEMA / IS 4503 exchangers; API 650 tanks.
- Design P above maximum operating P; corrosion allowance; joint efficiency.
- Hydrostatic test ≈ 1.3 × design pressure (ASME VIII Div. 1).
Example: Find the shell and 2:1 ellipsoidal head thickness of a 1.5 m vessel at 10 bar g, with S = 138 MPa, E = 0.85 and 3 mm corrosion allowance.
- P = 1.0 MPa, R = 750 mm.
- Shell: t = PR/(SE − 0.6P) = 1.0 × 750/(117.3 − 0.6) = 6.43 mm + 3 = 9.43 mm.
- Head: t = PD/(2SE − 0.2P) = 1500/(234.6 − 0.2) = 6.40 mm + 3 = 9.40 mm.
Answer: Use 10 mm plate for both (next standard size).
Process design (duties, sizes), mechanical design (materials, thickness, supports) and plant design (layout, piping, utilities, safety, cost). Data from handbooks, databanks, simulators and vendors. Codes: ASME VIII and IS 2825 for pressure vessels, TEMA and IS 4503 for exchangers, API 650/IS 803 for tanks, API 520/521 for relief, ASME B31.3 for piping, IBR for steam. Safety margins: design pressure and temperature, corrosion allowance, joint efficiency, hydrostatic test, relief valves, HAZOP.
- Design is iterative: assume, calculate, check.
- Codes give minimum safe practice, not optimum design.
- TEMA R is the heaviest-duty class.
- Always round thickness up to available plate.
Key formulas
- t = PR/(SE − 0.6P) + CA
- t_head = PD/(2SE − 0.2P) + CA
- P_test ≈ 1.3 P_design
Practice questions
The code for unfired pressure vessels in India is
- IS 2825
- IS 456
- IS 800
- IBR only
Show the answer
Answer: A. IS 2825 Indian standard.
TEMA class R exchangers are meant for
- refinery and severe service
- commercial service
- domestic use
- cryogenic service only
Show the answer
Answer: A. refinery and severe service Heaviest class.
Corrosion allowance is
- added to the calculated thickness
- subtracted from it
- ignored for steel
- the joint efficiency
Show the answer
Answer: A. added to the calculated thickness Extra metal for life.
Joint efficiency depends mainly on
- the extent of weld radiography
- the fluid
- the colour of paint
- the nozzle size
Show the answer
Answer: A. the extent of weld radiography Inspection.
Mechanical design is concerned with
- equilibrium stages
- wall thickness, supports and materials
- reaction kinetics
- plant economics only
Show the answer
Answer: B. wall thickness, supports and materials Strength.
Theory questions
Distinguish between process design, mechanical design and plant design. (5 marks)
Show the model answer
Process design determines the function: flow sheet, material and energy balances, operating conditions, equipment duties and sizes (area of an exchanger, number of stages and diameter of a column, volume of a reactor) using thermodynamic and transport data. Mechanical design ensures the equipment can withstand the conditions and be fabricated: materials of construction, thickness of shells and heads under internal/external pressure, nozzles and reinforcement, flanges, supports, wind and seismic loads, following codes. Plant design integrates equipment into a working plant: layout, piping and instrumentation, utilities, storage, safety and environmental systems, cost estimation and economics.
Why are codes and standards used in equipment design? Name important codes. (4 marks)
Show the model answer
Codes ensure safety (minimum thicknesses, allowable stresses, testing), consistency, interchangeability of parts, legal compliance and acceptance by inspectors and insurers, and they record accumulated experience. Examples: ASME BPVC Section VIII (pressure vessels), IS 2825 (Indian unfired pressure vessels), TEMA and IS 4503 (shell-and-tube exchangers), API 650 and IS 803 (storage tanks), API 520/521 (pressure relief), ASME B31.3 (process piping), IBR (boilers and steam piping in India), ASME B16.5 (flanges).
Design of heat-transfer equipment
Topics: Types of heat exchanger; design of double-pipe heat exchangers; design of shell-and-tube heat exchangers; design of multiple-effect evaporators.
Exchanger types and double-pipe design
Heat exchangers include double-pipe (hairpin) exchangers for small duties; shell-and-tube exchangers, the workhorse of the process industry; plate (gasketed, brazed, welded) exchangers for high efficiency with clean fluids; spiral, plate-fin and air-cooled exchangers; and evaporators, condensers and reboilers, which involve a change of phase. Choice depends on duty, pressures and temperatures, fouling and cleaning, materials and cost.
A double-pipe exchanger is a tube inside a larger pipe, assembled as U-shaped hairpins. One fluid flows in the inner tube and the other in the annulus, usually counter-current. Design steps: (1) heat balance for the duty and unknown temperature; (2) LMTD; (3) choose which fluid goes where (the more fouling, corrosive or high-pressure fluid in the tube); (4) velocities and Reynolds numbers; (5) film coefficients — inner tube h_i from Dittus–Boelter or Sieder–Tate; annulus h_o using the equivalent diameter D_e = (D₂² − D₁²)/D₁ for heat transfer (and D₂ − D₁ for friction); (6) overall coefficient with fouling 1/U_o = D_o/(D_ih_i) + D_o ln(D_o/D_i)/(2k_w) + 1/h_o + R_do + R_di(D_o/D_i); (7) area A = Q/(U_oLMTD), length and number of hairpins; (8) pressure drops, including return-bend losses; (9) adjust if limits are exceeded.
- Annulus heat transfer: D_e = (D₂² − D₁²)/D₁; friction: D₂ − D₁.
- 1/U_o = D_o/(D_ih_i) + D_o ln(D_o/D_i)/(2k_w) + 1/h_o + R_d.
- A = Q/(U LMTD); hairpins = length/(2 × leg).
- Use for areas below about 10–15 m².
Example: Water (1 kg/s) is cooled from 80 to 50 °C by 1.5 kg/s of water at 25 °C in a double-pipe exchanger (1″ tube in 2″ pipe). With h_i ≈ 8400 and h_o ≈ 2130 W/m²·K and R_d = 0.0004, find U_o, area and hairpins (6 m legs).
- Q = 1 × 4.19 × 30 = 125.7 kW; T_co = 25 + 125.7/(1.5 × 4.18) = 45.0 °C.
- LMTD = ((80 − 45) − (50 − 25))/ln(35/25) = 29.7 K.
- 1/U_o = 33.4/(26.6 × 8400) + 0.0334 ln(33.4/26.6)/90 + 1/2130 + 0.0004 ⇒ U_o ≈ 907 W/m²·K.
- A = 125 700/(907 × 29.7) = 4.67 m²; length = 4.67/(π × 0.0334) = 44.5 m ⇒ 4 hairpins of 2 × 6 m.
Answer: About 4.7 m², 4 hairpins, U_o ≈ 900 W/m²·K.
Shell-and-tube exchangers (Kern) and multiple-effect evaporators
A shell-and-tube exchanger has a bundle of tubes fixed in tube sheets inside a cylindrical shell; baffles direct the shell-side fluid across the tubes and support them. TEMA types describe the front head, shell and rear head (e.g. BEM fixed tube sheet, AES floating head, U-tube). Typical choices: 19.05 or 25.4 mm tubes, 16–20 ft (4.88–6.1 m) long, triangular pitch 1.25 d_o (or square for cleaning), 1, 2, 4 or more tube passes, baffle spacing 0.2–1.0 shell diameter with 25 % cut. The corrosive, fouling, high-pressure or cooling-water stream usually goes in the tubes.
Kern’s design procedure: duty and temperatures; LMTD and correction factor F_t for multipass flow (keep F_t > 0.75–0.8, else more shells); assume U; area; number of tubes N_t = A/(πd_oL) for the chosen passes; bundle diameter D_b = d_o(N_t/K₁)^(1/n₁) and shell diameter; tube-side velocity, Reynolds number and h_i; shell-side cross-flow area A_s = (p_t − d_o)D_sl_B/p_t, mass velocity, equivalent diameter d_e = 1.10(p_t² − 0.917d_o²)/d_o (triangular) and h_o = j_hRePr^(1/3)k/d_e (or 0.36Re^0.55Pr^(1/3)k/d_e); overall U with fouling; compare with the assumed U and repeat; finally check tube- and shell-side pressure drops against the allowable values.
A multiple-effect evaporator reuses the vapour from each effect to heat the next, which boils at lower pressure. Design: total evaporation from a solids balance; assume temperature drops (inversely proportional to U); energy balances on each effect for steam and evaporation (with boiling-point rise and enthalpies of solutions where needed); areas A_i = Q_i/(U_iΔT_i); adjust ΔT_i ∝ A_i until the areas are equal. Forward feed suits hot feed and heat-sensitive products; backward feed suits cold feed and viscous products. Steam economy is roughly 0.8 × number of effects.
- TEMA BEM, AES, U-tube.
- D_b = d_o(N_t/K₁)^(1/n₁); D_s = D_b + clearance.
- Shell side (Kern): h_o = 0.36(k/d_e)Re^0.55Pr^⅓.
- MEE: equal areas by adjusting ΔT_i ∝ A_i.
Example: A 1–2 exchanger cools 5 kg/s of kerosene (c_p 2.47 kJ/kg·K) from 150 to 90 °C with water heated 25 → 40 °C. With U = 700 W/m²·K, find the area and the number of 20 mm × 4.88 m tubes.
- Q = 5 × 2.47 × 60 = 741 kW; LMTD = (110 − 65)/ln(110/65) = 85.5 K.
- R = 60/15 = 4, P = 15/125 = 0.12 ⇒ F_t = 0.979.
- A = 741 000/(700 × 0.979 × 85.5) = 12.6 m².
- N_t = 12.6/(π × 0.020 × 4.88) = 42 tubes.
Answer: 12.6 m², 42 tubes (2 passes) in a shell of about 220 mm.
Example: A forward-feed triple effect concentrates 10 000 kg/h from 5 % to 25 % solids with steam at 120 °C and the last effect at 52 °C. Estimate the evaporation and the steam economy (λ ≈ 2300 kJ/kg, feed 40 °C).
- Evaporation = 10 000(1 − 0.05/0.25) = 8000 kg/h.
- Energy balances with equal areas give steam ≈ 3440 kg/h.
- Economy = 8000/3440 = 2.33.
Answer: 8000 kg/h evaporated with about 3440 kg/h steam (economy ≈ 2.3).
Heat exchangers, LMTD and evaporators
The driving force in an exchanger is the log-mean temperature difference: LMTD = (ΔT₁ − ΔT₂)/ln(ΔT₁/ΔT₂), using the end differences. Counter-current flow gives a larger LMTD than co-current for the same terminal temperatures. Q = UA·LMTD.
Evaporators concentrate solutions with steam. Steam economy = kg of water evaporated per kg of steam; multiple-effect evaporators reuse vapour from one effect to heat the next, raising economy roughly in proportion to the number of effects.
- LMTD = (ΔT₁ − ΔT₂)/ln(ΔT₁/ΔT₂)
- Q = U A LMTD
- Economy = water evaporated / steam used
Example: Hot fluid 150 → 100 °C, cold 30 → 80 °C. Find the LMTD for counter-current and co-current flow.
- Counter: ΔT₁ = 150 − 80 = 70, ΔT₂ = 100 − 30 = 70, so LMTD = 70 °C.
- Co-current: ΔT₁ = 120, ΔT₂ = 20, LMTD = 100/ln 6 ≈ 55.8 °C.
Answer: 70 °C and ≈ 55.8 °C
Example: With U = 333 W/m²K and LMTD = 70 °C, what area transfers 100 kW?
- A = Q/(U·LMTD) = 100 000/(333 × 70).
- ≈ 4.29 m².
Answer: ≈ 4.3 m²
Exchanger types: double-pipe, shell-and-tube, plate, spiral, air-cooled, evaporators. Double-pipe design: heat balance, LMTD, h_i and h_o (annulus D_e), U with fouling, area and hairpins, pressure drop. Shell-and-tube (Kern): TEMA types, tube layout, F_t correction, assume U, tubes and shell size, h_i and shell-side h_o, check U and ΔP, iterate. Multiple-effect evaporators: solids balance, effect energy balances, equal-area adjustment, forward vs backward feed, economy.
- Put fouling or high-pressure fluid in the tubes.
- Keep F_t above 0.75–0.8.
- Water velocity in tubes 1–2.5 m/s.
- Economy ≈ 0.8 × number of effects.
Key formulas
- Q = UAF_tΔT_lm
- D_e (annulus) = (D₂² − D₁²)/D₁
- N_t = A/(πd_oL)
- h_o = 0.36(k/d_e)Re^0.55Pr^⅓
- A_i = Q_i/(U_iΔT_i)
Practice questions
The equivalent diameter for heat transfer in an annulus is
- D₂ − D₁
- (D₂² − D₁²)/D₁
- D₂
- (D₂ + D₁)/2
Show the answer
Answer: B. (D₂² − D₁²)/D₁ Only the inner wall transfers heat.
If F_t falls below about 0.75 you should
- add tube passes
- use more shells in series
- reduce U
- ignore it
Show the answer
Answer: B. use more shells in series Temperature cross.
Baffles on the shell side
- reduce turbulence
- direct flow across tubes and support them
- carry tube-side fluid
- remove fouling
Show the answer
Answer: B. direct flow across tubes and support them Cross-flow.
Backward feed in an evaporator suits
- hot feed
- cold feed and viscous product
- heat-sensitive feed only
- single effects
Show the answer
Answer: B. cold feed and viscous product Hot effect sees the thick liquor.
In an equal-area MEE design the temperature drops are adjusted in proportion to
- U_i
- A_i
- λ
- feed rate
Show the answer
Answer: B. A_i ΔT_i ∝ A_i, then normalise.
Theory questions
Outline the design procedure for a shell-and-tube heat exchanger by Kern’s method. (6 marks)
Show the model answer
1. Specification: flows, inlet/outlet temperatures, duty from heat balance; physical properties. 2. Allocate fluids (tube side: corrosive, fouling, high-pressure, cooling water). 3. LMTD and F_t from R and P; choose shells/passes. 4. Assume U from tables; area A = Q/(UF_tΔT_lm). 5. Choose tube size, length, pitch; N_t = A/(πd_oL); bundle and shell diameter. 6. Tube side: velocity (1–2.5 m/s for water), Re, Pr, h_i. 7. Shell side: baffle spacing and cut, A_s, G_s, d_e, Re, h_o (Kern correlation). 8. Overall U with fouling and wall resistance; compare with assumed U; iterate. 9. Pressure drops on both sides against allowable; adjust passes, baffle spacing or shell size. 10. Mechanical design and TEMA specification sheet.
Describe the design of a multiple-effect evaporator with equal heating surfaces. (6 marks)
Show the model answer
Given feed rate and concentration, product concentration, steam pressure and last-effect pressure: (1) total evaporation by solids balance; (2) boiling points including boiling-point rise; total available ΔT = T_steam − T_last − ΣBPR; (3) assume ΔT_i ∝ 1/U_i; (4) energy balances on each effect (feed arrangement forward/backward) with enthalpies or c_p and λ to find steam and vapour from each effect; (5) areas A_i = Q_i/(U_iΔT_i); (6) if unequal, set ΔT_i′ = ΔT_iA_i/Ā, normalise to the total and repeat until equal; (7) steam economy = total evaporation/steam; condenser duty from last-effect vapour.
Design of mass-transfer equipment
Topics: Design of tray and packed columns for binary and multicomponent distillation; column internals.
Stages, reflux and tray column sizing
A distillation design fixes the separation (key components and their recoveries or purities), the operating pressure (so the condenser can use cooling water if possible) and then the number of stages and reflux. For binary systems the McCabe–Thiele construction gives stages graphically; for multicomponent systems the shortcut Fenske–Underwood–Gilliland method is used for preliminary design: Fenske gives the minimum stages at total reflux, N_min = ln[(x_LK/x_HK)_D(x_HK/x_LK)_B]/ln α_LK; Underwood gives the minimum reflux; Gilliland’s correlation (e.g. Eduljee: Y = 0.75(1 − X^0.5668)) gives the stages at the chosen reflux (usually 1.2–1.5 R_min); Kirkbride locates the feed. Rigorous stage-by-stage simulation follows in practice.
Real trays reach only part of equilibrium: overall efficiency E_o (O’Connell correlation, typically 50–80 %) converts theoretical stages into actual trays. Column diameter is set by flooding: the flooding velocity u_f = C_sb(σ/20)^0.2√((ρ_L − ρ_V)/ρ_V), with C_sb from Fair’s chart as a function of the flow parameter F_LV = (L/V)√(ρ_V/ρ_L) and tray spacing; design at 70–85 % of flooding, then add the downcomer area. Tray layout then fixes weir height and length, hole area (sieve trays, 5–12 % of active area), downcomer size, and checks weeping at minimum load, entrainment, downcomer back-up and pressure drop. Height = trays × spacing (0.45–0.6 m) + space at the top for vapour disengagement and at the bottom for liquid hold-up.
- Fenske: minimum stages; Underwood: minimum reflux; Gilliland: N at R.
- R ≈ 1.2–1.5 R_min.
- Actual trays = theoretical/E_o.
- u_f = C_sb(σ/20)^0.2√((ρ_L − ρ_V)/ρ_V); design at 70–85 %.
Example: Separate 40 mol % benzene (α = 2.5) into 95 % distillate and 5 % bottoms, saturated-liquid feed, R = 1.3 R_min, E_o = 0.65. Find N_min, R_min, N and the number of real trays.
- N_min = ln(19 × 19)/ln 2.5 = 5.889/0.916 = 6.43.
- q = 1: x* = 0.4, y* = 2.5 × 0.4/(1 + 1.5 × 0.4) = 0.625 ⇒ R_min = (0.95 − 0.625)/(0.625 − 0.4) = 1.44; R = 1.88.
- Gilliland: X = (1.88 − 1.44)/2.88 = 0.151 ⇒ Y = 0.75(1 − 0.151^0.5668) = 0.493 ⇒ N = (0.493 + 6.43)/0.507 = 13.7.
- Real trays = (13.7 − 1)/0.65 = 19.5 ⇒ 20 trays.
Answer: About 13.7 theoretical stages, 20 real trays.
Example: Vapour 3 kg/s (ρ_V = 2.8 kg/m³), liquid 4.5 kg/s (ρ_L = 800 kg/m³), σ = 20 mN/m, 0.6 m spacing. Find the column diameter at 80 % of flooding with 12 % downcomer area.
- F_LV = 1.5√(2.8/800) = 0.089; Fair chart C_sb ≈ 0.095 m/s.
- u_f = 0.095 × √((800 − 2.8)/2.8) = 1.60 m/s; u_n = 1.28 m/s.
- A_n = (3/2.8)/1.28 = 0.84 m²; A_c = 0.84/0.88 = 0.95 m² ⇒ D = 1.10 m.
Answer: D ≈ 1.1 m.
Packed columns and column internals
Packed columns suit small diameters (< 0.6–1 m), corrosive systems (ceramic or plastic packings), vacuum service (low pressure drop) and foaming liquids. Packings are random (Raschig rings, Pall rings, saddles, modern high-performance rings) or structured (corrugated metal sheets or gauze, with high capacity and low pressure drop). Height is designed by transfer units: Z = H_OG × N_OG, where N_OG measures the difficulty of the separation (for dilute absorption with straight equilibrium and operating lines, the Colburn equation) and H_OG the efficiency of the packing (from correlations such as Onda or Cornell, or vendor data); for distillation, Z = N_stages × HETP. Diameter is chosen at 60–80 % of flooding from the generalised pressure-drop correlation (Eckert/Strigle) or a design pressure drop (e.g. 20–40 mm water per m for absorbers).
Column internals make the column work as designed: trays (sieve, valve, bubble-cap) with weirs and downcomers; for packed columns, liquid distributors (orifice, trough, spray), redistributors every 3–6 m or 5–10 diameters (liquid tends to migrate to the wall), packing supports and hold-down plates; feed and reflux inlets, chimney trays and draw-off sumps; demisters at the top; manholes and vortex breakers. Poor distribution or damaged internals are common causes of poor column performance.
- Z = H_OG × N_OG (or N × HETP).
- Colburn: N_OG for dilute systems.
- Design at 60–80 % flooding.
- Distributors and redistributors are essential.
Example: A dilute gas (y₁ = 0.02) is scrubbed to 95 % recovery with pure solvent; m = 1.2, L = 1.5 L_min, H_OG = 0.6 m. Find N_OG and the packed height.
- y₂ = 0.001; L_min/G = (0.019)/(0.02/1.2) = 1.14 ⇒ L/G = 1.71, A = L/(mG) = 1.425.
- N_OG = ln[(1 − 1/1.425)(0.02/0.001) + 1/1.425]/(1 − 1/1.425) = ln(5.965 + 0.702)/0.298 = 6.36.
- Z = 0.6 × 6.36 = 3.8 m.
Answer: N_OG ≈ 6.4; about 3.8 m of packing.
Distillation and the McCabe–Thiele method
McCabe–Thiele assumes constant molar overflow. The rectifying operating line is y = [R/(R + 1)]x + x_D/(R + 1); the q-line through the feed point has slope q/(q − 1) (vertical for saturated liquid feed). Steps between the equilibrium curve and the operating lines count the theoretical stages.
Total reflux gives the minimum number of stages (Fenske): N_min = ln[(x_D/(1 − x_D))((1 − x_B)/x_B)]/ln α. Minimum reflux gives infinite stages; operating reflux is usually 1.2–1.5 times the minimum.
- Rectifying line slope R/(R + 1), intercept x_D/(R + 1)
- Saturated liquid feed: q = 1, vertical q-line
- Fenske: minimum stages at total reflux
Example: With R = 2 and x_D = 0.9, find the slope and intercept of the rectifying line.
- Slope = 2/3 ≈ 0.667.
- Intercept = 0.9/3 = 0.3.
Answer: y = 0.667x + 0.3
Example: Find N_min for x_D = 0.95, x_B = 0.05 and α = 2.5.
- N_min = ln(19 × 19)/ln 2.5 = 5.889/0.916.
- ≈ 6.4 stages (including the reboiler).
Answer: ≈ 6.4
Distillation design: pressure, keys, recoveries; McCabe–Thiele (binary) and Fenske–Underwood–Gilliland with Kirkbride (shortcut multicomponent); R ≈ 1.2–1.5 R_min; tray efficiency; diameter from flooding (Fair chart, 70–85 %), downcomer area; tray layout checks (weeping, entrainment, back-up, pressure drop); height. Packed columns: random and structured packings; Z = H_OG N_OG or N × HETP; diameter from flooding or pressure drop. Internals: trays, distributors, redistributors, supports, demisters.
- Choose pressure so the condenser uses cooling water.
- Packed columns for small, corrosive or vacuum service.
- Redistribute liquid every 5–10 diameters.
- Check minimum-load weeping as well as flooding.
Key formulas
- N_min = ln[(x_LK/x_HK)_D(x_HK/x_LK)_B]/ln α
- Y = 0.75(1 − X^0.5668)
- u_f = C_sb(σ/20)^0.2√((ρ_L − ρ_V)/ρ_V)
- Z = H_OG N_OG
Practice questions
Fenske’s equation gives
- minimum reflux
- minimum stages at total reflux
- feed location
- column diameter
Show the answer
Answer: B. minimum stages at total reflux Total reflux.
The column diameter is fixed mainly by
- the number of stages
- the flooding velocity
- feed composition only
- reboiler duty only
Show the answer
Answer: B. the flooding velocity Vapour capacity.
Packed columns are preferred for
- very large diameters
- corrosive and vacuum service
- high liquid rates only
- all cases
Show the answer
Answer: B. corrosive and vacuum service Low ΔP, plastic/ceramic.
Liquid redistributors are needed because liquid
- evaporates
- migrates towards the wall
- freezes
- foams
Show the answer
Answer: B. migrates towards the wall Maldistribution.
The usual operating reflux is about
- R_min
- 1.2–1.5 R_min
- 5 R_min
- total reflux
Show the answer
Answer: B. 1.2–1.5 R_min Economic optimum.
Theory questions
Explain the Fenske–Underwood–Gilliland shortcut method for distillation design. (6 marks)
Show the model answer
Specify feed, key components and their split. Fenske (total reflux, constant α): N_min = ln[(x_LK/x_HK)_D(x_HK/x_LK)_B]/ln α_avg; also distributes non-keys. Underwood (minimum reflux): solve Σα_ix_iF/(α_i − θ) = 1 − q for θ between α_HK and α_LK, then R_min + 1 = Σα_ix_iD/(α_i − θ). Choose R = 1.2–1.5R_min. Gilliland: correlation between X = (R − R_min)/(R + 1) and Y = (N − N_min)/(N + 1) (Eduljee: Y = 0.75(1 − X^0.5668)) gives N. Kirkbride gives the feed stage: log(N_R/N_S) = 0.206 log[(B/D)(x_HK/x_LK)_F(x_LK,B/x_HK,D)²]. Then actual trays = N/E_o.
How is the diameter of a sieve-tray column determined? (5 marks)
Show the model answer
Calculate vapour and liquid loads at the top and bottom (and feed) sections. Flow parameter F_LV = (L/V)√(ρ_V/ρ_L). From Fair’s flooding chart (tray spacing curves) read C_sb; correct for surface tension: C = C_sb(σ/20)^0.2. Flooding velocity u_f = C√((ρ_L − ρ_V)/ρ_V). Choose design velocity 70–85 % of u_f (lower for foaming systems). Net area A_n = volumetric vapour flow/u_n; add downcomer area (10–15 %) to get column area; D = √(4A_c/π); take the larger of top and bottom diameters (or swage). Then check entrainment, weeping, downcomer back-up and pressure drop with a tray layout.
Design of condensers and reboilers
Topics: Design of condensers and reboilers.
Condensers
Condensers remove the latent heat of a vapour, usually with cooling water. Configurations: horizontal shell-side condensation (vapour outside tubes, water inside) — the most common for column overheads; vertical tube-side condensation (downflow) for reflux and subcooling; and reflux (knock-back) condensers. Partial condensers return liquid reflux and send vapour forward; total condensers condense everything. Non-condensable gases must be vented because a small fraction greatly lowers the coefficient.
Nusselt’s theory treats the condensate as a laminar film draining under gravity. For condensation outside a horizontal tube: h = 0.725[k³ρ(ρ − ρ_v)gλ/(μd_oΔT_f)]^¼, where ΔT_f = T_sat − T_wall; on a bank of N_r tube rows the average coefficient falls by about N_r^(−1/6) (Kern) because condensate from upper tubes thickens the film below. In vertical tubes, h depends on the condensate loading per unit perimeter, with turbulence beyond Re ≈ 1800. The wall temperature is found by equating the condensing flux with the flux to the coolant; then U, LMTD (the condensing side is isothermal for a pure vapour) and area follow. Condensing coefficients are typically 1000–2000 W/m²·K for organics and 5000–15 000 for steam.
- Horizontal shell-side condensers are most common.
- Nusselt: h = 0.725[k³ρ²gλ/(μd_oΔT)]^¼ × N_r^(−1/6).
- Vent non-condensables.
- Steam ≫ organics in condensing h.
Example: Condense 5000 kg/h of an organic vapour (λ = 380 kJ/kg) at 80 °C with water 30 → 40 °C. With a condensing h of about 1230 W/m²·K, water-side 3500 W/m²·K and fouling 0.0003 m²K/W, find U, area and water flow.
- Q = (5000/3600) × 380 = 528 kW; water = 528/(4.18 × 10) = 12.6 kg/s = 45 t/h.
- 1/U = 1/1230 + 1/3500 + 0.0003 ⇒ U ≈ 714 W/m²·K.
- LMTD = (50 − 40)/ln(50/40) = 44.8 K; A = 528 000/(714 × 44.8) = 16.5 m².
Answer: U ≈ 714 W/m²·K, A ≈ 16.5 m² (66 tubes 20 mm × 4 m), 45 t/h of water.
Reboilers
A reboiler supplies the boil-up at the bottom of a column. Kettle reboilers have a tube bundle in a large shell with a disengagement space above the liquid; they act as a theoretical stage, are easy to design and tolerant, but expensive and with long residence time. Thermosyphon reboilers (vertical or horizontal) circulate liquid naturally by the density difference between liquid in the column sump and the vapour–liquid mixture in the exchanger; they are cheap and compact but need careful hydraulic design. Forced-circulation reboilers use a pump, for viscous or fouling liquids. Internal reboilers (bundles inside the column bottom) are used for small duties.
Boiling occurs in the nucleate regime, where bubbles growing and leaving the surface give high coefficients that rise steeply with heat flux. The Mostinski correlation gives h_nb = 0.104P_c^0.69q^0.7[1.8(P/P_c)^0.17 + 4(P/P_c)^1.2 + 10(P/P_c)^10] (P_c in bar, q in W/m²). If the flux exceeds the critical (maximum) heat flux, bubbles merge into a vapour film and the coefficient collapses; the Zuber equation q_max = 0.131λρ_v^½[σg(ρ_L − ρ_v)]^¼ or Mostinski’s q_max = 3.67×10⁴P_c(P/P_c)^0.35(1 − P/P_c)^0.9 W/m² estimate it, and kettle reboilers are designed for at most about 70 % of q_max (with bundle corrections). The heating medium (steam, hot oil) and fouling set the rest of the resistance; area = duty/design flux.
- Kettle: robust, acts as a stage; thermosyphon: cheap, compact; forced: viscous liquids.
- Mostinski nucleate boiling correlation.
- Critical heat flux: Zuber or Mostinski; design ≤ 70 % q_max.
- Area = Q/q_design.
Example: A kettle reboiler must supply 1500 kW to a hydrocarbon boiling at 120 °C and 5 bar (P_c = 42.5 bar) with steam at 160 °C (h_s = 8000, fouling 0.0003). Find the design flux and area.
- Solve q(1/h_nb(q) + 1/8000 + 0.0003) = 40 K with Mostinski: q ≈ 64 kW/m², h_nb ≈ 5000 W/m²·K.
- Critical flux (Zuber) ≈ 370 kW/m²; 70 % = 260 kW/m² > 64, so ΔT limits the design.
- A = 1500/64 = 23.5 m².
Answer: About 64 kW/m² and 23.5 m².
Condensers: horizontal shell-side, vertical tube-side, reflux; total and partial; vent non-condensables; Nusselt film theory with Kern’s row correction; wall temperature from flux balance; U, LMTD, area. Reboilers: kettle, thermosyphon (vertical/horizontal), forced circulation, internal; nucleate boiling (Mostinski); critical heat flux (Zuber, Mostinski) and design below 70 % of it; area from design flux.
- Subcooling zones need separate calculation.
- Thermosyphons need adequate static head.
- Film boiling must be avoided.
- Hot oil and steam are common heating media.
Key formulas
- h = 0.725[k³ρ(ρ − ρ_v)gλ/(μd_oΔT_f)]^¼ N_r^(−1/6)
- h_nb = 0.104P_c^0.69q^0.7F(P_r)
- q_max = 0.131λρ_v^½[σg(ρ_L − ρ_v)]^¼
- A = Q/q
Practice questions
Non-condensable gases in a condenser
- raise the coefficient
- greatly lower the coefficient
- have no effect
- raise the pressure drop only
Show the answer
Answer: B. greatly lower the coefficient Diffusion barrier.
On a bank of horizontal tubes, the average condensing coefficient
- rises with the number of rows
- falls with the number of rows
- is unchanged
- becomes zero
Show the answer
Answer: B. falls with the number of rows Thicker film below.
A kettle reboiler
- acts as an equilibrium stage
- has no vapour space
- needs a pump
- is used only for gases
Show the answer
Answer: A. acts as an equilibrium stage Vapour disengages.
Exceeding the critical heat flux leads to
- nucleate boiling
- film boiling and a collapse of h
- condensation
- subcooling
Show the answer
Answer: B. film boiling and a collapse of h Vapour blanket.
Thermosyphon reboilers circulate liquid by
- a pump
- density difference
- gravity alone without boiling
- steam ejectors
Show the answer
Answer: B. density difference Natural circulation.
Theory questions
Derive or state Nusselt’s equation for film condensation and discuss its use in condenser design. (5 marks)
Show the model answer
Assumptions: laminar condensate film, gravity drainage, linear temperature profile in the film, negligible vapour shear and subcooling. For a vertical plate h = 0.943[k³ρ(ρ − ρ_v)gλ/(μLΔT)]^¼; for a horizontal tube h = 0.725[k³ρ(ρ − ρ_v)gλ/(μd_oΔT)]^¼. In tube banks the condensate from upper tubes falls on lower ones: average h_N = h₁N^(−1/6) (Kern) or N^(−1/4) (Nusselt). In design: find the wall temperature by equating condensing and coolant fluxes (iteration), compute U including coolant film, wall and fouling, area from Q/(U·LMTD); vent non-condensables and allow for vapour shear (which raises h) and subcooling zones.
Compare kettle and thermosyphon reboilers. (5 marks)
Show the model answer
Kettle: bundle in an oversized shell with vapour space; liquid flows from the column, boils on the bundle, vapour returns; a weir keeps the bundle submerged and bottoms product overflows. Pros: acts as a stage, stable, handles wide turndown, easy design. Cons: large shell (cost), long residence time (fouling of heat-sensitive liquids). Vertical thermosyphon: liquid from the sump flows down to the bottom of a vertical exchanger, partly vaporises in the tubes, and the lighter mixture rises back to the column; driven by density difference. Pros: cheap, compact, short residence time, high coefficients. Cons: needs headroom and careful circulation design, less stable at low ΔT or vacuum, not a full stage. Horizontal thermosyphons suit large duties; forced circulation for viscous/fouling liquids.
Notes, examples and questions were written for this studio; the prescribed books are listed in the studio for reference.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Process Equipment Design-I Studio?
Codes, exchangers, evaporators and columns. Design types and codes (ASME VIII, IS 2825, TEMA), vessel thickness, double-pipe and shell-and-tube exchangers (Kern), triple-effect evaporators, FUG distillation, tray and packed column sizing, condensers and reboilers from the ASTU CHE241504 syllabus.
What can I do in the Process Equipment Design-I Studio?
Vessel and head thickness by ASME VIII; Double-pipe and shell-and-tube design; Multiple-effect evaporators; Columns, condensers and kettle reboilers.
Is the Process Equipment Design-I Studio free?
Yes. It is free and runs in your browser with no sign-up.