IITIAN1997 STUDIO

Design Thinking

ES104 · 35 questions with answers

Open this subject studio →

Basics of Design Thinking

Topics: Definition, need and objectives; concepts and brainstorming; stages Empathize, Define, Ideate, Prototype, Test with examples; creative thinking process; problem solving.

What design thinking is, and why engineers need it

Design thinking is a human-centred, iterative way of solving problems. It starts from the needs and experiences of the people who will use a product or service, rather than from a technology or from the designer’s assumptions, and it moves forward by making quick, cheap versions of ideas and testing them with real users. It was popularised by IDEO and the Stanford d.school, but its roots lie in industrial design and engineering practice.

Engineers are trained to solve well-defined problems with known methods. Many real problems are ill-defined (“wicked”): users cannot state what they need, requirements conflict, and the right question is unclear. Design thinking helps in exactly this zone. Its objectives are to understand users deeply, frame the right problem, generate many alternative solutions, and reduce the risk of building the wrong thing by learning early and cheaply.

A useful picture is the double diamond (UK Design Council): in the first diamond the team diverges to discover as much as possible about the problem, then converges to define one clear problem; in the second it diverges to develop many possible solutions, then converges to deliver the one that works best. Each diamond alternates divergent thinking (many options, no judgement) and convergent thinking (choosing and refining).

  • Human-centred, iterative, experimental
  • For ill-defined (“wicked”) problems
  • Understand users; frame the right problem; many ideas; test early
  • Double diamond: discover, define, develop, deliver
  • Alternate divergent and convergent thinking

Example: A college wants fewer students to be late for the 9 a.m. class. Show how a technology-first approach and a design-thinking approach would differ.

  1. Technology-first: install a biometric attendance system and penalise lateness.
  2. Design thinking: first talk to and observe late students; perhaps the hostel mess opens at 8:45 or the only bus arrives at 9:05.
  3. The real fix may be changing the mess or bus timing, which is cheaper and better.

Answer: Understanding users first can reveal a different, simpler problem

Example: Classify each as divergent or convergent: (a) listing 40 ideas for reusing plastic bottles; (b) scoring the ideas against cost and safety; (c) interviewing ten different kinds of users; (d) writing one problem statement.

  1. (a) and (c) widen the options or information: divergent.
  2. (b) and (d) narrow down to a choice: convergent.

Answer: (a) divergent, (b) convergent, (c) divergent, (d) convergent

The five stages: Empathize, Define, Ideate, Prototype, Test

Empathize: understand users through observation, interviews and immersion (trying the experience yourself), noting what they say, do, think and feel, especially workarounds and frustrations. Define: turn the findings into a clear, human-centred problem statement, often as a point-of-view statement (“[user] needs [need] because [insight]”) or a “How might we …?” question.

Ideate: generate a large number of possible solutions without judging them, then select a few promising ones. Prototype: build cheap, quick versions (sketches, paper models, cardboard mock-ups, simple apps, role-play) that make an idea tangible enough to test. Test: put prototypes in front of real users, observe and listen, and learn what works and what does not.

The stages are not a straight line. Testing often sends the team back to define the problem better or to ideate again, and empathy continues throughout. Short repeated cycles (iterations) are the heart of the method: each loop costs little and reduces uncertainty.

  • Empathize: observe, interview, immerse
  • Define: POV statement; “How might we …?”
  • Ideate: quantity first, judge later
  • Prototype: cheap, quick, testable
  • Test: learn from users; iterate back

Example: Write a point-of-view statement and a “How might we” question for: elderly patients at a district hospital struggle to find the right counter.

  1. POV: Elderly first-time patients need to reach the correct counter quickly because long walks and confusing signs tire and worry them.
  2. HMW: How might we guide elderly patients to the right counter without them needing to read small signs?

Answer: As above: user, need, insight; then an open “How might we” question

Example: Plan one simple activity for each stage for redesigning the college canteen queue.

  1. Empathize: watch the queue at lunch and interview five students and the cashier. Define: “Students need to get food within their 30-minute break.”
  2. Ideate: brainstorm 30 ideas (pre-ordering, separate tea counter …). Prototype: a paper token system for one day.
  3. Test: time the queue and ask users; refine.

Answer: Observation, a problem statement, many ideas, a one-day paper prototype, timed test

Brainstorming and creative thinking

Brainstorming, introduced by Alex Osborn, is a group method for generating many ideas quickly. Its central rule is to separate idea generation from evaluation: criticism during generation stops people offering unusual ideas, which are often the seeds of good ones. A facilitator keeps time, writes every idea, and encourages building on others’ suggestions.

Variations help shy or large groups. Brainwriting (6-3-5: six people each write three ideas in five minutes, then pass the sheet on) avoids domination by loud voices. SCAMPER prompts new ideas by asking what could be Substituted, Combined, Adapted, Modified (magnified or minified), Put to another use, Eliminated or Reversed. Mind maps spread ideas around a central theme, and analogy borrows solutions from nature or other industries (biomimicry).

The creative thinking process is often described in four steps: preparation (gathering information and understanding the problem), incubation (stepping away so the mind can work unconsciously), illumination (the insight or “aha” moment) and verification (checking and developing the idea). Creativity can be trained: curiosity, tolerance of ambiguity, and a willingness to look foolish matter more than talent.

  • Defer judgement; aim for quantity; welcome wild ideas
  • Brainwriting 6-3-5 for fair participation
  • SCAMPER prompts
  • Mind maps; analogies; biomimicry
  • Preparation, incubation, illumination, verification

Example: Apply SCAMPER to an ordinary school bag to get at least four new ideas.

  1. Substitute: waterproof tarpaulin for cloth (Assam monsoon). Combine: bag plus a small seat for waiting at bus stops.
  2. Adapt: hiking-bag hip belt to spread weight. Modify: wider, padded straps.
  3. Put to other use: bag that unfolds into a rain cover. Eliminate: zips that jam, replaced by roll-top. Reverse: open from the back so it cannot be picked in crowds.

Answer: Several ideas such as waterproof roll-top, seat bag, hip belt, anti-theft back opening

Example: A group of 6 runs a 6-3-5 brainwriting session for 6 rounds. How many ideas are written? And how many pairs of 12 shortlisted ideas could be tried as combinations?

  1. Each round: 6 people × 3 ideas = 18; 6 rounds give 108 ideas.
  2. Pairs from 12 ideas: 12 × 11/2 = 66.

Answer: 108 ideas; 66 possible pairs

Problem solving with design thinking

Design thinking treats problem solving as two linked tasks: finding the right problem and then solving it well. Root-cause tools help with the first. The five whys ask “why?” repeatedly to move from a symptom to a cause that can be acted on; the fishbone (Ishikawa) diagram sorts possible causes into categories such as people, methods, machines, materials, measurement and environment.

Reframing the problem often opens better solutions. “Design a better alarm clock” limits ideas to clocks; “help students wake up on time” allows changes to sleep, schedules or habits. Stating the problem in terms of the user’s goal, not a particular solution, keeps options open. Constraints (budget, materials, standards, time) should be listed explicitly, as they shape good solutions rather than merely limiting them.

Finally, the chosen solution should be tested against the original need with measurable criteria, such as time saved, cost, error rate or user satisfaction, so that the team knows whether the problem has really been solved and what to improve next.

  • Find the right problem, then solve it well
  • Five whys; fishbone (Ishikawa) diagram
  • Reframe around the user’s goal, not a solution
  • List constraints explicitly
  • Measure success against the original need

Example: Reframe: “Design a bigger water tank for the hostel.”

  1. A bigger tank is one solution; the user goal is reliable water at peak times.
  2. Reframed: “How might we ensure every room has water during the 6–8 a.m. rush?”, which also allows staggered pumping, leak repair or low-flow taps.

Answer: Reframe around the need: reliable water at peak hours

Example: List fishbone categories and one possible cause in each for “3D-printed parts in the lab often warp”.

  1. Machine: uneven bed. Material: damp filament. Method: no brim or wrong bed temperature.
  2. Environment: draughts from a fan. People: untrained users. Measurement: bed level not checked.

Answer: Machine, material, method, environment, people, measurement

Design thinking is a human-centred, iterative approach to solving problems: understand users deeply, frame the right problem, generate many ideas, build quick prototypes and test them with users. The Stanford d.school model has five stages — Empathize, Define, Ideate, Prototype, Test — which loop back as learning grows. Brainstorming produces many ideas quickly by deferring judgement; creative thinking alternates divergent (generate options) and convergent (select the best) phases.

  • Empathize: observe, interview, immerse; build empathy maps (says, thinks, does, feels).
  • Define: write a point-of-view/problem statement: “[User] needs [need] because [insight]”; “How might we…?” questions.
  • Ideate: brainstorming, mind maps, SCAMPER, worst-possible-idea; quantity over quality first.
  • Prototype: cheap, fast, rough models to learn (paper, cardboard, storyboard, role play).
  • Test: get user feedback, refine or return to earlier stages.
  • Need: wicked/ill-defined problems, user adoption, reduced risk of failure, innovation.

Key formulas

  • Problem statement: User + Need + Insight
  • How might we …?

Practice questions

The first stage of design thinking is

  1. Ideate
  2. Empathize
  3. Test
  4. Prototype
Show the answer

Answer: B. Empathize Understand users first.

Brainstorming rules include

  1. criticise every idea
  2. defer judgement
  3. one idea per person
  4. start with the solution
Show the answer

Answer: B. defer judgement Quantity first, judge later.

“How might we…?” questions are written in the

  1. Define stage
  2. Test stage
  3. Prototype stage
  4. Launch stage
Show the answer

Answer: A. Define stage They frame opportunities.

Design thinking is

  1. linear and one-pass
  2. iterative and human-centred
  3. only for artists
  4. cost accounting
Show the answer

Answer: B. iterative and human-centred Loops between stages.

Theory questions

Define design thinking. (2 marks)

Show the model answer

A human-centred, iterative problem-solving approach that empathises with users, defines the problem, ideates, prototypes and tests solutions.

Explain the role of empathy in design thinking with an example. (4 marks)

Show the model answer

Designers learn users’ real needs, feelings and context by observation and interviews, avoiding assumptions. Example: observing elderly people struggling with tablet strips leads to an easy-open medicine dispenser.

Explain the five stages of the design thinking process with a suitable example. (10 marks)

Show the model answer

Example: reducing queues in the college canteen. Empathize: observe and interview students and staff. Define: “Students need to get lunch within the 30-min break because classes resume.” Ideate: pre-order app, more counters, combo meals, token display. Prototype: paper app mock-up and a trial pre-order counter. Test: run for a week, measure waiting time and feedback, iterate.

Process of Product Design

Topics: Engineering product design process, design thinking approach, stages of product design, examples of best product designs and functions, assignment on engineering product design.

The engineering product design process

The classical engineering design process moves from a recognised need to a product ready for production. Problem definition turns the need into a design specification: a list of measurable requirements (functions, performance, size, weight, cost, life, safety, standards) with targets and limits. Conceptual design generates and evaluates alternative working principles. Embodiment and detail design fix the layout, materials, dimensions, tolerances and manufacturing methods, producing drawings and calculations.

Prototyping and testing then confirm that the design meets the specification, followed by design for manufacture and assembly (DFMA), production planning, launch, and feedback from use. Throughout, design reviews check the work against the specification, and changes are documented.

A good specification separates demands (must be met) from wishes (desirable), and states each requirement as a number with a unit where possible: “carries 25 kg at a speed of at least 0.5 m/s” rather than “strong and fast”. Vague requirements cannot be tested, and an untestable requirement usually ends up ignored.

  • Need → specification → concepts → detail design → prototype and test → production
  • Specification: measurable targets and limits
  • Demands (must) vs wishes (nice to have)
  • Design reviews against the specification
  • DFMA: design for manufacture and assembly

Example: Rewrite as measurable specifications: “The solar lamp should be bright, last long, and be cheap.”

  1. Bright: at least 100 lumens on the high setting.
  2. Long-lasting: 6 hours on high from one full charge; battery life of 1000 cycles.
  3. Cheap: retail price under ₹800.

Answer: ≥ 100 lm; ≥ 6 h per charge, 1000 cycles; under ₹800

Example: Sort these into demands and wishes for a hospital bed: (a) holds a 150 kg patient; (b) available in several colours; (c) brakes on all wheels; (d) folds for storage.

  1. Safety and function are demands: (a) and (c).
  2. Desirable extras are wishes: (b) and (d).

Answer: Demands: (a), (c); wishes: (b), (d)

Design thinking within product design

Design thinking adds to the engineering process a strong front end: deep user research before the specification is written, and frequent user testing of early prototypes. It reduces the risk that a technically excellent product fails because nobody wants it or can use it. The engineering process, in turn, brings rigour, analysis and manufacturability to design thinking’s ideas.

Customer needs are gathered by interviews, observation and surveys, then translated into engineering characteristics. The Kano model sorts features into basic needs (expected; their absence causes dissatisfaction, as with brakes on a scooter), performance needs (more is better, as with mileage) and delighters (unexpected features that please, as with a USB charging port on a bus seat). Quality function deployment (the “house of quality”) links each customer need to measurable engineering targets.

Concept selection compares alternatives systematically, often with a weighted decision matrix: list the criteria from the specification, give each a weight that reflects its importance, score each concept on each criterion, and add the weighted scores. The method does not replace judgement but makes the reasoning visible and helps a team agree.

  • User research before the specification
  • Kano: basic, performance, delighter features
  • House of quality links needs to engineering targets
  • Weighted decision matrix for concept selection
  • Rigour plus empathy

Example: Classify for an electric scooter using Kano: (a) working brakes, (b) range, (c) an app that finds charging points, (d) a horn.

  1. Basic (expected): working brakes, a horn.
  2. Performance (more is better): range.
  3. Delighter (unexpected): the charging-point app (until it becomes common).

Answer: (a), (d) basic; (b) performance; (c) delighter

Example: Choose between three designs scored 1–10 on cost (weight 0.3), ease of use (0.2), durability (0.25) and safety (0.25): A (8, 6, 7, 9), B (6, 9, 8, 7), C (9, 5, 6, 6).

  1. A: 0.3×8 + 0.2×6 + 0.25×7 + 0.25×9 = 2.4 + 1.2 + 1.75 + 2.25 = 7.60.
  2. B: 1.8 + 1.8 + 2.0 + 1.75 = 7.35. C: 2.7 + 1.0 + 1.5 + 1.5 = 6.70.

Answer: Design A (7.60), narrowly ahead of B

Stages of product design and the product life cycle

A product passes through planning (market and need analysis, business case), concept development, system-level design (architecture and modules), detail design, testing and refinement, and production ramp-up. Companies usually place “gates” between stages where management decides, on the evidence, whether to continue, change direction or stop: the stage-gate process.

Designers must think beyond the factory gate. The product life cycle covers raw-material extraction, manufacture, distribution, use, maintenance and end of life (reuse, recycling or disposal). Life-cycle thinking leads to designs that use less energy in use, can be repaired (screws instead of glue, standard parts), and can be taken apart for recycling. Many costs are locked in early: decisions made at the concept stage typically fix most of the product’s eventual cost, though little money has yet been spent.

Important design-for-X considerations include design for manufacture (simple shapes, standard processes), assembly (fewer parts, self-locating features), reliability, maintenance, safety, ergonomics, environment, and cost. Good products balance them for their particular users and market.

  • Planning, concept, system, detail, test, ramp-up
  • Stage-gate reviews: go, change, stop
  • Life cycle: materials, making, use, end of life
  • Early decisions lock in most cost
  • Design for X: manufacture, assembly, repair, environment

Example: A phone is glued shut so its battery cannot be replaced. Which design-for-X goals does this conflict with, and what is a better design?

  1. It conflicts with design for maintenance (repair) and for environment (longer life, recycling).
  2. Better: screws or clips and a replaceable battery module, with a standard connector.

Answer: Repairability and environment; use a replaceable battery

Example: Reduce the part count: a bracket is held by four bolts, four nuts and eight washers. Suggest one design-for-assembly change.

  1. Sixteen fasteners must each be handled and tightened.
  2. Use two bolts into tapped holes (no nuts), or a snap-fit or self-locating tab with one screw.

Answer: Fewer, simpler fasteners: for example two bolts into tapped holes

Examples of well-designed products

Well-designed products fit their users and context, perform their function reliably, are easy to understand and use, and are affordable to make and maintain. Often their excellence is invisible: a ball-point pen or a pressure cooker works so well that we forget it is a designed object. A pressure cooker’s weighted whistle regulates pressure, and a separate safety valve and gasket release prevent explosions if the vent blocks: layered safety by design.

Indian examples show design for local needs. The Jaipur Foot, a rubber-based prosthetic limb, costs a small fraction of imported limbs and allows squatting, sitting cross-legged and walking barefoot on rough ground. The Mitticool clay refrigerator keeps vegetables and water cool by evaporation with no electricity. The UPI QR payment system lets anyone pay with a scan, regardless of bank or phone model.

Studying good and bad designs builds judgement. Ask what need the product meets, who uses it and how, what its key functions and features are, how it is made, what it costs, how it fails, and how it might be improved. Don Norman’s ideas of affordances (a handle invites pulling) and feedback (a click confirms a switch) explain why some products feel obvious and others confuse.

  • Fit users and context; reliable; easy; affordable
  • Layered safety (pressure cooker)
  • Design for local needs: Jaipur Foot, Mitticool, UPI
  • Analyse: need, users, function, making, cost, failure
  • Affordances and feedback

Example: Explain the safety design of a pressure cooker.

  1. The weighted whistle lifts at the working pressure and lets steam escape, regulating pressure.
  2. If the vent blocks, a safety valve (fusible plug) releases at a higher pressure; the gasket can also be pushed out through a window in the lid.
  3. Multiple independent safeguards prevent a dangerous explosion.

Answer: Regulating whistle plus independent safety valve and gasket release

Example: A door has a flat plate on the push side and a handle on the pull side. Which design principle does this use?

  1. A handle affords pulling; a flat plate affords only pushing.
  2. Users choose correctly without reading a sign.

Answer: Affordance: the shape shows how to use it

Engineering product design moves from need identification through specification, concept generation and selection, embodiment (layout, materials, form), detail design (dimensions, tolerances, drawings), prototyping and testing, to production and launch. Combining it with design thinking keeps the user at the centre while engineering methods ensure the product is functional, safe, manufacturable and economical. Good products show clear function, ergonomics, aesthetics, reliability and sustainability.

  • Stages: need → specification → concepts → selection (decision matrix) → embodiment → detail → prototype/test → production.
  • Product design specification (PDS): performance, cost, size, weight, environment, life, safety, standards.
  • Concept selection by weighted decision (Pugh) matrix.
  • Design for manufacture and assembly (DFMA): fewer parts, standard parts, easy assembly.
  • Examples: the paper clip (simple function), ergonomic toothbrush, smartphone (integration), LED bulb (energy).

Key formulas

  • Weighted score = Σ weightᵢ × ratingᵢ

Practice questions

A Pugh matrix is used for

  1. concept selection
  2. stress analysis
  3. costing only
  4. marketing
Show the answer

Answer: A. concept selection Compare concepts against criteria.

DFMA aims to

  1. increase part count
  2. make products easy and cheap to manufacture and assemble
  3. add decoration
  4. avoid standards
Show the answer

Answer: B. make products easy and cheap to manufacture and assemble Design for manufacture and assembly.

Detailed dimensions and tolerances are fixed in

  1. need identification
  2. detail design
  3. ideation
  4. launch
Show the answer

Answer: B. detail design Detail stage.

The product design specification lists

  1. only the price
  2. requirements the product must meet
  3. employee names
  4. advertising slogans
Show the answer

Answer: B. requirements the product must meet PDS.

Theory questions

What is a product design specification? (2 marks)

Show the model answer

A document listing all requirements a product must satisfy — function, performance, cost, size, materials, safety, standards, environment, life — used to judge concepts.

How does design thinking complement the engineering design process? (4 marks)

Show the model answer

Design thinking adds deep user understanding, problem framing and rapid user-tested prototypes; the engineering process adds analysis, specifications, materials and manufacturability — together they produce products that are desirable, feasible and viable.

Describe the stages of engineering product design with an example product. (10 marks)

Show the model answer

Example: a portable solar lantern. Need: light for villages without grid. PDS: 8 h light, < ₹800, rugged, waterproof. Concepts: LED + Li-ion, LED + lead-acid, foldable panel. Selection: weighted matrix. Embodiment: housing, panel angle, battery placement. Detail: circuit, PCB, drawings, tolerances. Prototype and test: run-time, drop and rain tests, user feedback. Production and launch.

Prototyping and Testing

Topics: What a prototype is, why prototype, rapid prototype development, ergonomic challenges, testing.

What a prototype is and why we prototype

A prototype is an early, simplified version of a product built to explore, test or communicate an idea before full development. It can be anything from a sketch or paper mock-up to a working model nearly identical to the final product. Its purpose is learning: answering specific questions about whether the idea works, whether users understand it, and whether it can be made.

Prototypes are classified by fidelity and purpose. Low-fidelity prototypes (paper, cardboard, foam, role-play, clickable sketches) are cheap and fast, and good for testing concepts and user flows early. High-fidelity prototypes look and work like the final product and test detailed performance, appearance and manufacture. A “looks-like” prototype tests form and appearance; a “works-like” prototype tests function; a proof-of-concept tests one critical principle.

Prototyping early saves money because changes become far more expensive as development proceeds: a change on paper costs little, a change after tooling costs a great deal, and a recall after launch costs much more. Each prototype should be built to answer a stated question, with no more fidelity than that question needs.

  • Prototype: an early version built to learn
  • Low fidelity: cheap, fast, early
  • High fidelity: close to final; detailed tests
  • Looks-like, works-like, proof-of-concept
  • Build to answer a question; changes cost more later

Example: Choose a suitable prototype for each question: (a) Will users understand the menu of a new canteen app? (b) Will a new gear survive 10 000 cycles? (c) Does a new kettle shape feel good in the hand?

  1. (a) A paper or clickable low-fidelity mock-up of the screens.
  2. (b) A works-like prototype in the real material, tested on a rig.
  3. (c) A looks-like model in foam or 3D print with the right weight added.

Answer: Paper screens; a real-material gear test; a foam or printed looks-like model

Example: Why build three ₹200 cardboard prototypes instead of one ₹20 000 machined one at the start?

  1. Early ideas are uncertain; each cheap prototype can test a different idea and be thrown away.
  2. Mistakes found early cost little to fix; the expensive model is built once the design is stable.

Answer: Cheap, fast learning reduces risk before costly work

Rapid prototyping

Rapid prototyping covers methods that turn a computer model into a physical part quickly, mostly additive manufacturing (3D printing), which builds parts layer by layer. Fused deposition modelling (FDM) extrudes molten plastic filament (PLA, ABS, PETG) and is cheap and common in colleges. Stereolithography (SLA) cures liquid resin with light for fine detail. Selective laser sintering (SLS) fuses powder and makes strong parts without support structures.

Other rapid methods include laser cutting of sheet (acrylic, plywood, cardboard) for flat or slotted assemblies, CNC machining for strong metal parts, and electronic prototyping with breadboards and microcontroller boards (Arduino, ESP32) with sensors, which let a working gadget be assembled in hours. Software prototypes are built with no-code tools or simple apps.

For 3D printing, design for the process: avoid large overhangs beyond about 45° (or add supports), orient parts so loads do not pull layers apart, allow clearances of about 0.2–0.5 mm between mating parts, and use infill of 15–30 % for most prototypes to save time and plastic. Estimate cost from the mass of filament used plus machine time.

  • Additive: FDM (filament), SLA (resin), SLS (powder)
  • Laser cutting, CNC, breadboards and microcontrollers
  • Overhangs over ~45° need supports
  • Clearances ~0.2–0.5 mm; infill 15–30 %
  • Cost ≈ material mass × price + machine time

Example: An FDM part uses 62 g of PLA filament costing ₹1200 per kg. Find the material cost.

  1. Mass in kg: 0.062 kg.
  2. Cost = 0.062 × 1200 = ₹74.40.

Answer: About ₹74

Example: A printed hinge pin of 5 mm diameter must turn freely in a printed hole. What hole size would you model, and why?

  1. FDM holes print slightly undersize and surfaces are rough.
  2. Allow about 0.3–0.5 mm clearance: model the hole at about 5.4 mm.

Answer: About 5.3–5.5 mm

Ergonomics and its challenges

Ergonomics (human factors) designs products, tools and workplaces to fit the people who use them, for comfort, safety and efficiency. It covers physical aspects (body size, posture, strength, reach, repetitive strain), cognitive aspects (how easily controls and displays are understood, mental workload, error), and environmental aspects (lighting, noise, heat).

Anthropometry measures human body dimensions. Because people vary, designers use percentiles: the 5th percentile value is exceeded by 95 % of people, the 95th by only 5 %. Clearances (door heights, leg room) are designed for a large person (95th percentile or above, plus allowances for shoes and clothing); reaches (shelf heights, control positions) for a small person (5th percentile); and adjustable items (seats, desks) to cover the range between. Data must match the user population: Indian body dimensions differ from European data.

Ergonomic challenges in prototypes include awkward grips, controls placed out of reach, displays hard to read, forces too high for weaker users, and products designed only for right-handed or able-bodied users. Universal (inclusive) design aims for products usable by as many people as possible, including the elderly, children and people with disabilities, without special adaptation.

  • Physical, cognitive and environmental ergonomics
  • Percentiles: 5th and 95th
  • Clearances: large user; reaches: small user; adjustable: the range
  • Use data for the actual population
  • Universal design: usable by as many as possible

Example: Suppose adult male stature in a population has mean 165 cm and SD 6.5 cm (illustrative). Find the 5th and 95th percentiles.

  1. For a normal distribution, the 5th and 95th percentiles are at mean ∓ 1.645 SD.
  2. 165 − 1.645 × 6.5 = 154.3 cm; 165 + 1.645 × 6.5 = 175.7 cm.

Answer: About 154 cm and 176 cm

Example: Which percentile would you design for: (a) the height of a bus door; (b) the height of an emergency stop button; (c) a bicycle seat?

  1. (a) A clearance: design for the tall user (95th–99th percentile plus shoes and headroom).
  2. (b) A reach: design so the small user (5th percentile) can reach it.
  3. (c) Make it adjustable to cover roughly the 5th to 95th percentile range.

Answer: (a) 95th+, (b) 5th, (c) adjustable range

Testing prototypes

Testing checks a prototype against the specification and against users’ needs. Engineering tests measure performance, strength, durability, safety and environmental resistance on test rigs, often to standard test methods. Usability tests watch representative users try realistic tasks, measuring success rate, time taken, errors and satisfaction, and listening as they think aloud.

Good tests are planned: state what you want to learn, define tasks and success criteria, use real or representative users, avoid leading them (do not explain the design first), and record what happens. Small repeated rounds work well; a widely quoted rule of thumb is that about five users per round reveal most usability problems, because each user tends to find a fair share of the common ones.

Results feed back into the design. Separate observations (“3 of 5 users pressed the wrong button”) from interpretations (“the label is unclear”), prioritise problems by severity and frequency, fix them, and test again. A/B testing compares two versions with larger groups to see which performs better.

  • Engineering tests: performance, strength, safety, durability
  • Usability tests: success, time, errors, satisfaction
  • Plan goals, tasks, criteria; do not lead users
  • About 5 users per round; iterate
  • Separate observation from interpretation; prioritise

Example: If each test user finds on average 31 % of the usability problems, independently, what share is found by 5 users? By 3? By 10?

  1. Share found by n users = 1 − (1 − 0.31)ⁿ.
  2. n = 5: 1 − 0.69⁵ = 0.84; n = 3: 1 − 0.69³ = 0.67.
  3. n = 10: 1 − 0.69¹⁰ = 0.98, a small gain for twice the effort.

Answer: About 84 %, 67 % and 98 %

Example: Rewrite as an observation, not an interpretation: “Users hate the new switch.”

  1. State what was seen, by how many users.
  2. Leave the explanation for a separate line.

Answer: For example: “4 of 5 users pressed the switch twice because it gave no click or light to show it had turned on.”

A prototype is an early model built to learn and to test ideas. Low-fidelity prototypes (sketches, paper, cardboard, storyboards) are cheap and fast; high-fidelity ones (3D-printed parts, working electronics) look and work like the product. Rapid prototyping uses 3D printing, laser cutting and CNC to iterate quickly. Ergonomics fits the product to human body sizes (anthropometry), strength and comfort. Testing with real users reveals problems early when they are cheap to fix.

  • Why prototype: communicate ideas, test function, get feedback, reduce risk and cost.
  • Fidelity: low (paper, foam) → high (functional).
  • Rapid prototyping: FDM/SLA 3D printing, laser cutting, CNC, breadboards.
  • Ergonomic checks: reach, grip, posture, force, visibility, fatigue; 5th–95th percentile users.
  • Usability testing: tasks, observation, think-aloud, metrics (time, errors, satisfaction).

Practice questions

A paper mock-up of an app screen is a

  1. high-fidelity prototype
  2. low-fidelity prototype
  3. final product
  4. specification
Show the answer

Answer: B. low-fidelity prototype Cheap and quick.

Anthropometry deals with

  1. human body measurements
  2. animal behaviour
  3. soil testing
  4. electrical safety
Show the answer

Answer: A. human body measurements Used in ergonomics.

The main reason to prototype early is to

  1. impress investors only
  2. learn and find problems cheaply
  3. avoid testing
  4. increase cost
Show the answer

Answer: B. learn and find problems cheaply Fail fast, learn fast.

Which is a rapid prototyping process?

  1. forging
  2. 3D printing
  3. casting a ship hull
  4. painting
Show the answer

Answer: B. 3D printing Additive manufacturing.

Theory questions

What is a prototype? (2 marks)

Show the model answer

An early sample or model of a product built to test a concept or process and learn from it before full production.

Why are ergonomic considerations important in product design? (4 marks)

Show the model answer

They ensure the product fits users’ body dimensions and abilities, improving comfort, safety, efficiency and satisfaction, and reducing fatigue and injury (e.g. handle diameter, keyboard angle, chair height).

Explain rapid prototyping and the testing of prototypes with users. (8 marks)

Show the model answer

Rapid prototyping: quickly fabricating models directly from CAD by additive (FDM, SLA, SLS) or subtractive (CNC, laser) processes, allowing several design iterations in days. Testing: define goals, select representative users, give realistic tasks, observe, record time/errors/feedback, analyse and refine the design; repeat.

Standards and Standardisation

Topics: Objectives and importance of standardisation in society and industry; Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS): objectives, roles and functions; BIS Act; marking and certification of products and processes.

Standards and standardisation: objectives and importance

A standard is a document, established by consensus and approved by a recognised body, that gives rules, guidelines or characteristics for products, processes or services, aimed at the best order in a given context. Standardisation is the activity of making and applying standards. Familiar examples are paper sizes (A4), screw threads, electric plugs and sockets, pipe sizes, the QR code, and test methods for drinking water.

The objectives of standardisation are interchangeability and compatibility (a bulb from any maker fits any holder), variety reduction (fewer sizes and grades, so lower stocks and cost), quality and safety (minimum performance and safe limits), protection of consumers and the environment, efficient communication through common terms, symbols and drawings, and easier trade between regions and countries.

Preferred numbers are a classic tool of variety reduction. The Renard series space sizes in geometric steps, so that each is a fixed percentage larger than the last: R5 has five steps per decade (ratio about 1.58: 1, 1.6, 2.5, 4, 6.3, 10) and R10 has ten (ratio about 1.26: 1, 1.25, 1.6, 2, 2.5, 3.15, 4, 5, 6.3, 8, 10). Many standard ratings and sizes come from these series.

  • Standard: consensus document approved by a recognised body
  • Interchangeability, variety reduction, quality, safety
  • Consumer protection, common language, trade
  • Renard series: R5 (× 1.58), R10 (× 1.26)
  • Examples: A4 paper, threads, plugs, test methods

Example: A workshop stocks bolts in 40 lengths. It standardises on 12. Give three benefits.

  1. Lower inventory and storage cost; bulk buying at better prices.
  2. Fewer mistakes and faster assembly; easier replacement from any supplier.

Answer: Lower stock and cost, fewer errors, easier replacement

Example: Generate the R10 series from 1 to 10 and find its step ratio.

  1. Ratio = 10^(1/10) = 1.259.
  2. Rounded values: 1, 1.25, 1.6, 2, 2.5, 3.15, 4, 5, 6.3, 8, 10.

Answer: Ratio ≈ 1.26; series as listed

Standardisation in society and industry

Standards exist at several levels. International bodies include ISO (most fields), IEC (electrical and electronic) and ITU (telecommunications). National bodies, such as BIS in India, BSI in the UK and ANSI in the USA, publish national standards, often adopting or harmonising with international ones. Professional and industry bodies (ASME for boilers and pressure vessels, ASTM for materials testing, IEEE for electrical and computing) write standards for their fields, and companies write their own for internal parts and processes.

For society, standards protect health and safety (helmets, gas cylinders, electrical appliances, food and water quality), let consumers compare and trust products, and enable networks to work: mobile phones, the internet, payment cards and UPI all rely on standards. For industry, they cut costs, open markets, simplify contracts (“to IS 2062”) and spread good practice, including management-system standards such as ISO 9001 (quality) and ISO 14001 (environment).

Engineers use standards daily, for material grades, drawing practice, tolerances, test procedures, and safety codes, and should cite the exact standard and year, because standards are revised. A design that meets the relevant standards is easier to approve, certify and defend.

  • International ISO, IEC, ITU; national BIS, BSI, ANSI
  • Industry: ASME, ASTM, IEEE; company standards
  • Society: safety, trust, networks
  • Industry: cost, markets, contracts, ISO 9001/14001
  • Cite the exact standard and year

Example: Which body’s standards would you consult for: (a) a boiler’s pressure parts; (b) the safety of an electrical appliance internationally; (c) drinking water in India?

  1. (a) ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code (and the Indian Boiler Regulations in India).
  2. (b) IEC standards.
  3. (c) BIS: IS 10500.

Answer: ASME (and IBR); IEC; BIS IS 10500

Example: Give two ways in which standards make UPI payments possible.

  1. A common payment protocol lets any bank’s app pay any other bank’s customer.
  2. A standard QR-code format lets every phone camera and app read any merchant’s code.

Answer: Common protocols and a common QR format

The Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS)

The Bureau of Indian Standards is India’s national standards body. It grew out of the Indian Standards Institution (ISI), set up in 1947, and became BIS under the BIS Act of 1986; the BIS Act, 2016, which came into force in 2017, now governs it. BIS works under the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, has its headquarters in New Delhi, and represents India in ISO and IEC.

Its objectives are the harmonious development of standardisation, marking and quality certification of goods, and attention to related matters. Its roles include formulating Indian Standards through technical committees of manufacturers, users, consumers, government, laboratories and academia, by consensus, with drafts circulated for public comment; certifying products, systems and services; running testing laboratories; hallmarking precious metals; training; and consumer awareness.

Indian Standards are numbered with the year of the version, for example IS 10500:2012 (drinking water) or IS 1239 (steel tubes). Standards are reviewed periodically, at least every five years, and revised, amended, reaffirmed or withdrawn as technology changes. Anyone can propose a new standard or comment on drafts.

  • ISI 1947 → BIS (Act 1986); BIS Act 2016 (in force 2017)
  • Under the consumer affairs ministry; HQ New Delhi; member of ISO and IEC
  • Technical committees; consensus; public comment
  • Roles: standards, certification, testing, hallmarking, training
  • IS number with year, e.g. IS 10500:2012; periodic review

Example: List four functions of BIS.

  1. Formulate and publish Indian Standards.
  2. Certify products (ISI mark), management systems and services; hallmark gold and silver.
  3. Operate testing laboratories; promote standards and protect consumers.

Answer: Standards, certification, hallmarking, testing (and training, awareness)

Example: Why does an Indian Standard show a year, as in IS 10500:2012?

  1. Standards are revised; the year identifies which version applies.
  2. Contracts and test reports must state the exact version used.

Answer: To identify the version, since standards are revised

The BIS Act, marking and certification

The BIS Act, 2016 established BIS as the national standards body, widened its scope to goods, services, processes, systems and articles, and allowed multiple ways of showing conformity, including self-declaration. It empowers the central government to make certification compulsory for products that affect health, safety, the environment or national security, through Quality Control Orders, and it sets penalties for misuse of the Standard Mark or sale of non-conforming goods where certification is compulsory.

Under the product certification scheme, a manufacturer whose product and factory pass BIS tests and inspection receives a licence to apply the ISI mark, with the IS number and licence number, and BIS checks continuing compliance through surveillance and market samples. Many products need the mark compulsorily, for example packaged drinking water, LPG cylinders, cement, electrical appliances and two-wheeler helmets.

Other schemes include hallmarking of gold and silver jewellery (each item carries a six-character Hallmark Unique Identification, HUID), the Compulsory Registration Scheme for electronics and IT goods (phone chargers, power banks, LED lamps) based on tests in BIS-recognised laboratories, management-system certification, and the Eco Mark. Consumers can verify licences and hallmarks with the BIS Care app and file complaints.

  • BIS Act 2016: wider scope; compulsory certification via Quality Control Orders
  • ISI mark with IS number and licence number; surveillance
  • Compulsory examples: packaged water, LPG cylinders, cement, helmets
  • Hallmark with HUID; CRS (R-number) for electronics
  • Verify with the BIS Care app

Example: You buy a two-wheeler helmet with an ISI mark. What should you check, and how?

  1. The mark should show the relevant IS number (IS 4151) and a licence number (CM/L-…).
  2. Verify the licence number in the BIS Care app; a missing or fake mark means it may not meet the safety standard.

Answer: IS number, licence number, and verify in BIS Care

Example: A phone charger carries a BIS logo with an R-number, not an ISI mark. Is that correct?

  1. Electronics and IT goods such as chargers come under the Compulsory Registration Scheme.
  2. Their mark shows a registration number (R-…) rather than an ISI licence.

Answer: Yes: it is registered under CRS

A standard is a document, established by consensus and approved by a recognised body, giving rules or characteristics for products, processes or services. Standardisation brings interchangeability, safety, quality, lower cost through mass production, and trade. The Bureau of Indian Standards, the national standards body under the BIS Act 2016 (earlier ISI), formulates Indian Standards (IS), certifies products with the ISI mark, hallmarks gold and silver jewellery, registers electronics (CRS) and runs laboratories.

  • Levels: company, national (BIS), regional, international (ISO, IEC).
  • Objectives: simplification, interchangeability, quality, safety, health, environment, consumer protection, trade.
  • BIS Act 2016 replaced the BIS Act 1986; BIS functions under the Ministry of Consumer Affairs.
  • ISI mark: product certification (e.g. cement, LPG cylinders, helmets — some mandatory).
  • Hallmarking for gold/silver; Compulsory Registration Scheme for electronics; ECO mark for eco-friendly products.
  • ISO/IEC Guide 59: good practices for standardisation (consensus, openness, transparency).

Practice questions

The Bureau of Indian Standards works under the Ministry of

  1. Defence
  2. Consumer Affairs
  3. Railways
  4. Education
Show the answer

Answer: B. Consumer Affairs Department of Consumer Affairs.

The current BIS Act is of

  1. 1947
  2. 1986
  3. 2016
  4. 2022
Show the answer

Answer: C. 2016 BIS Act 2016.

The ISI mark certifies

  1. gold purity
  2. conformity of industrial products to Indian Standards
  3. software licences
  4. films
Show the answer

Answer: B. conformity of industrial products to Indian Standards Gold uses hallmarking.

A major benefit of standardisation is

  1. interchangeability of parts
  2. higher variety of sizes
  3. more confusion
  4. higher cost
Show the answer

Answer: A. interchangeability of parts Parts fit everywhere.

Theory questions

What is a standard? (2 marks)

Show the model answer

A document established by consensus and approved by a recognised body that provides rules, guidelines or characteristics for products, processes or services to achieve order and quality.

State the importance of standardisation in industry and society. (5 marks)

Show the model answer

Interchangeability and mass production, lower cost, consistent quality, safety and health protection, environmental protection, easier trade and exports, consumer confidence, reduced variety and waste, common technical language.

Describe the objectives, roles and functions of the Bureau of Indian Standards and its certification schemes. (10 marks)

Show the model answer

Objectives: harmonious development of standardisation, marking and quality certification. Functions: formulate Indian Standards; product certification (ISI mark, mandatory for some items); hallmarking of jewellery; Compulsory Registration Scheme for electronics; management system certification (ISO 9001 etc.); laboratory testing; consumer awareness and training; international liaison with ISO/IEC. Legal basis: BIS Act 2016.

Innovative Product Design (Project)

Topics: Final presentation: solving a practical engineering problem through innovative product design and creative solutions.

Choosing a problem and researching users

The final project applies the whole method to a real problem. Good project problems are real (affecting identifiable people), important to them, within the team’s skills, budget and time, and testable. Local problems are often the best: water and sanitation in hostels, flood preparedness in Assam, safety on campus roads, accessibility for elderly or disabled people, farm and small-business tools, waste and energy use.

Start with empathy work: observe people in their setting, interview a range of users and stakeholders (not only friends), and try the experience yourself. Record quotes, photographs and observations. Then synthesise: group findings into themes (affinity mapping), identify insights (surprising truths about users), create a persona (a realistic profile of a typical user) and a journey map (the steps a user goes through, with pain points).

Write a sharp problem statement and success criteria before generating solutions. A good team agrees early on roles, a timeline with milestones, a budget, and how decisions will be made.

  • Real, important, feasible, testable problems; local ones are good
  • Observe, interview varied users, try it yourself
  • Affinity mapping, insights, persona, journey map
  • Problem statement and success criteria before ideas
  • Roles, timeline, budget, decision rules

Example: Write a persona for a project on flood alerts in a riverside village in Assam.

  1. Name and context: Mohan, 52, rice farmer near a Brahmaputra tributary; basic phone, limited data; reads Assamese.
  2. Needs and pains: early warning to move cattle and grain; alerts in English or by app do not reach him.

Answer: A realistic profile with context, goals, constraints and pain points

Example: List four stakeholders to interview for a project on making the college library easier to use at night.

  1. Students who study late, including hostel and day scholars.
  2. Library staff and security; the administration who approve timings and budgets.

Answer: Students, library staff, security, administration

From ideas to a concept

With a clear problem, the team diverges: brainstorm, brainwrite and use SCAMPER and analogies to produce many ideas, then cluster them and develop the most promising into a few distinct concepts, each sketched with how it works and how a user would use it.

Converge with evidence. Check each concept against the success criteria and constraints; use quick feasibility checks (rough calculations, cost estimates, material availability); and score concepts in a weighted decision matrix agreed by the team. Keep a record of why concepts were chosen or dropped.

Plan the prototype to test the riskiest assumptions first: if users may not want it, test desirability with a mock-up; if it may not work, test the critical function with a proof-of-concept; if it may be too costly, price the parts early.

  • Diverge: many ideas, then distinct concepts
  • Converge: criteria, feasibility checks, decision matrix
  • Record reasons for choices
  • Test the riskiest assumption first
  • Desirability, feasibility, viability

Example: For a low-cost hand-washing station for a school without running water, give one quick feasibility check for each of desirability, feasibility and viability.

  1. Desirability: show a cardboard mock-up to pupils and teachers; watch whether children can use it.
  2. Feasibility: check that a foot-pedal mechanism can lift a 20 L can’s tap with a child’s weight.
  3. Viability: price the parts locally (target under ₹1500) and ask who will refill and maintain it.

Answer: Mock-up test, mechanism check, cost and upkeep check

Example: Your matrix ranks concept B narrowly above A, but users in tests strongly preferred A. What should you do?

  1. The matrix only reflects the weights chosen; user evidence may show a criterion was under-weighted.
  2. Revisit the weights or combine A’s user-loved features into B, then test again.

Answer: Treat the matrix as a guide; let test evidence revise it

Building, testing and refining the solution

Build in rounds of rising fidelity: a rough model to test the concept with users, a functional model to test the mechanism or electronics, and a refined prototype for the final demonstration. Use the college workshop, 3D printers, laser cutters and microcontroller kits, and simple local materials such as bamboo, which is plentiful in Assam.

Test each round against the success criteria with real users, recording measurements and observations. Iterate: fix the biggest problems first. Keep a design log (dated notes, sketches, photographs, test results and decisions); it shows the journey, supports the final report, and protects the team’s intellectual property.

Consider safety, ergonomics, standards, cost and sustainability before calling the design finished: sharp edges, electrical safety, materials that are safe for children or food, and what happens at the end of the product’s life.

  • Rounds of rising fidelity
  • Workshop, 3D printing, laser cutting, microcontrollers, local materials
  • Test against success criteria with users
  • Design log: dates, sketches, photos, results
  • Check safety, ergonomics, standards, cost, sustainability

Example: A prototype rain-water filter is tested: target 20 L/h, measured 12, 13 and 11 L/h. What do you conclude, and what next?

  1. Mean = 12 L/h, 40 % short of the target.
  2. Find the bottleneck (filter area, head height, clogging), change one factor at a time, and retest.

Answer: Falls short by 40 %; diagnose and iterate

Example: Give three entries a good design-log page should contain.

  1. Date and what was built or changed (with a sketch or photo).
  2. Test method and results (numbers); decision taken and why.

Answer: Date and change, test results, decision with reason

Presenting the final design

The final presentation tells the story of the project: the problem and why it matters, who the users are and what was learnt about them (with evidence), the key insight, the ideas considered and why one was chosen, the prototype and how it works, test results against the success criteria, costs, and next steps. A short live demonstration or video is far more convincing than slides alone.

A pitch structure keeps it tight: hook (a striking fact or user story), problem, solution, proof (tests and user feedback), impact (who benefits and how much), and the ask (what support is needed). Visuals should show people, prototypes and data rather than walls of text.

Be honest about limitations and what did not work; examiners and investors value learning and clear thinking more than claims of perfection. Credit everyone who helped, and end with the key message stated in one sentence.

  • Tell the story: problem, users, insight, ideas, prototype, results
  • Demonstrate live or by video
  • Pitch: hook, problem, solution, proof, impact, ask
  • Visuals of people, prototypes and data
  • Be honest about limits; one-sentence key message

Example: Write a hook for a project on helmets for delivery riders that stay cool in Assam’s humid summer.

  1. Start with a vivid fact or story from your research.
  2. Link it straight to the problem your design solves.

Answer: For example: “Rajesh rides 80 km a day in 35 °C heat, and on most afternoons he hangs his helmet on the handlebar. We designed one he will keep on.”

Example: Your test showed the device worked for 8 of 10 users. How should you present this?

  1. Report it plainly: 8 of 10 completed the task unaided.
  2. Explain why the two failed and what change is planned.

Answer: State the result honestly with the cause and fix

The course ends with a team project: identify a real engineering problem, apply the full design thinking process, build and test a prototype, and present it. A strong presentation states the user and problem, shows evidence from empathy work, explains the idea and how it was chosen, demonstrates the prototype and test results, and discusses cost, standards, sustainability and next steps.

  • Choose a problem that real users face (campus, home, village, industry).
  • Evidence: interviews, photos, data, empathy map.
  • Show alternatives considered and why the final idea was chosen.
  • Prototype demonstration and test results.
  • Business view: cost, users, scalability; social/environmental impact; IPR possibilities.

Practice questions

A project presentation should begin with

  1. the price list
  2. the user and the problem
  3. the conclusion only
  4. team photos only
Show the answer

Answer: B. the user and the problem Context first.

Evidence from empathy work includes

  1. interview findings
  2. random guesses
  3. competitor slogans
  4. stock prices
Show the answer

Answer: A. interview findings User research.

Sustainability in design means

  1. ignoring materials
  2. reducing environmental and social harm over the life cycle
  3. using only plastics
  4. making it disposable
Show the answer

Answer: B. reducing environmental and social harm over the life cycle Life-cycle thinking.

The best prototype for a first user test is usually

  1. a final mould
  2. a quick low-cost model
  3. a printed brochure
  4. none
Show the answer

Answer: B. a quick low-cost model Learn cheaply.

Theory questions

What makes a design “innovative”? (2 marks)

Show the model answer

It solves a real need in a new or significantly better way that users adopt — novelty plus value.

How would you evaluate competing design ideas for your project? (4 marks)

Show the model answer

List criteria from the PDS and user needs (function, cost, safety, ease of use, manufacturability), weight them, score each idea in a decision matrix, prototype the top ones and test with users.

Prepare an outline of a final presentation for an innovative product solving a practical engineering problem of your choice. (10 marks)

Show the model answer

Title and team; problem and user (with data); empathy insights; problem statement and HMW questions; ideas generated and selection matrix; final concept with sketches/CAD; prototype and tests; results and iterations; cost, standards, sustainability; future work and IPR; conclusion.

Open this subject studio →